H5 Engine Comparision

Recently i was trying to get a game out for the mobile web. I wanted something that would be able to publish light weight game and had a good workflow for artists and developers to get things going as soon as possible.

Requirements:

Support for Mobile Web
GUI for level design
Workflow for UI animation
Support for 3D games
Ability to publish for Native Mobile [Good to Have]

The candidates:

Unity (unity tiny)
Cocos Creator
PlayCanvas
Three.js

I understand that other than the first two most of others don't have a way to publish to native mobile but the reason i choose them is because mobile web was the first priority and all of them seemed to have good support for it.

Criteria	Unity Tiny	Cocos Creator	Play Canvas	Three.js
3D WebGL	❌	✔️	✔️	✔️
UI Animation	✔️	✔️	❌	❌
Particle Systems	✔️	✔️	✔️	❌
Editor Support	✔️	✔️	✔️	✔️
Custom Shaders	Exp	Exp	✔️	✔️
Native Mobile	❌	✔️	❌	❌

Based on the above analysis, i picked cocos creator for making the game. I must say it was pretty fun experience. I was able to get the game done in about a weeks time. Our collision system was pretty basic. I struggled to get custom shaders in, but was able to finally get the light mapping shader to work. I couldn't get env mapping sorted though, that was the only time when i thought to myself that may be three.js would have been a better bet.

Comments

Epic Games Store on Steam Deck

EGS ( Epic Games Store ) like it or hate it, has been giving away free games and if you like free games you would have picked up atleast a couple of them. So given that some of those games are Deck Verified / Playable, its fair to assume you would like to install the EGS on the Deck. Installing EGS on Steam Deck Switch to Desktop Mode on your Steam Deck Download the EGS installer for windows from the Epic Store website: https://store.epicgames.com/en-US/download (using your web browser of choice) Open Steam in the desktop mode and add the installer as a non-steam game In the browse window, switch from .desktop files to All files. Select EpicInstaller-xxx.msi and add it to steam library. Find EpicInstaller in your steam library and open its' properties by hitting the "Gear" icon on the right ...

Flash animations in GoDot Engine

If you have not heard about GoDot game engine,.. you should check it out right away.. godotengine.org Last time, i wrote a blog post about my experience making a simple physics game to GoDot Engine. Though there are a bunch of free options announced during the GDC this year, i thought ill' contribute to the engine. The one piece that is most important for game dev is the pipeline for the engine. One of the most common tools used for 2D animations is Flash. I have been using a library called Super Animation for almost all the games we've made for android at TMG. It's a free tool which lets you convert swf files to .sam files. This file can then be loaded in Cocos2Dx using the Open source loader library https://github.com/raymondlu/super-animation-samples I thought it would be a good idea to port this cpp library to GoDot so that i understand how to write custom modules for the engine. This is the video of the module in action. I have expos...

Vehicle Physics (Godot 2D)

I've always been fascinated with the vehicle physics used in games. I played so many racing games / the hill climb games and every single time i would wonder wow that must be really hard to do. Thanks to the new generation of game development tools, developing physics based games has become almost a second nature to most people. I didn't want to be left out so i gave it a shot.. I tried setting up vehicle physics in GoDot Engine for a 2D vehicle. Here is what the vehicle scene looks like.. 2D vehicle setup in GoDot As you can see the body collision shape is not right but the rest of the stuff just works. The idea is simple think of what parts move along with the body vs what doesn't. I was kinda stuck setting up the pinJoint2D in GoDot, it actually clearly takes two nodes under the properties. This makes sure that the wheels are hinged to the DampingSpring2D. The Damping Spring2D takes two physics bodies(Body and the PinJoint2D) and makes it work like shock ab...

My Work

Search This Blog